Jan asked Lily what she would have been thinking as Anne attempted the walk in the woods and navigating around the mud. What would be going through Lily’s mind as she watched everything unfold.
Jan's eyes were still gleaming with laughter as she leaned back in her chair, catching her breath. "Honestly, Lily, I wish you were there. You would’ve died. Anne was so
confident, and then she—well, you know. But seriously, I gotta ask… if you had been there, watching her navigate the woods like that, especially the mud, what would’ve been going through your mind? Like, what would the running commentary be in your head?"
Lily, wiping away the last remnants of laughter-induced tears, took a moment to gather herself, offering a knowing smirk at Jan’s question. “Oh my God,” she said, pausing with a sly grin, “you mean if
I had been there watching Anne—Miss ‘I don't invite dirt into my life’—try to tiptoe her way across a muddy trail in
box-fresh Sperrys? Yeah, I’ve got a pretty vivid idea of what would’ve been running through my mind.”
Jan leaned in closer, intrigued. “Oh, this is going to be good.”
Lily chuckled, shaking her head slowly. “First of all, the second I saw Anne walking into the woods with her
spotless nautical outfit, I would’ve been like, ‘There’s no
way this ends without disaster.’ I know Anne. She’s so thoroughly
Anne. Like, of all the people in the world, she’s the one who will walk into Mother Nature looking like she’s about to host some private yacht club brunch.”
Jan giggled at the image. “True. She did have a yacht club vibe going.”
“She always does,” Lily agreed, still grinning. “So yeah, I probably would’ve just been watching her and thinking she’s got zero real clue what she’s in for. When Anne’s all confident about skirting nature—it’s like watching a deer prance onto the highway. You can’t look away because
you know something’s going to happen. It’s
just a matter of time.”
Jan nudged her playfully. “You sound like you knew she’d wipe out before it even started.”
Lily laughed. “Oh, absolutely. The second she’d walk up to that mud patch, all pristine and radiant, it would be like slow-motion in my brain. I would’ve read her movements—her little head tilt, sizing it up, probably planning the dainty path she'd take—
and, I’d be thinking:
‘Oh, hon, you’re about to be humbled by the universe.’"
Jan laughed so hard she almost snorted, trying to picture Anne’s confident expression as she balanced on the stepping stones. “Okay, but that moment when she started
actually picking her way across the stones, like she was pulling it off? What would you have thought then?”
Lily grinned wider, already imagining the scene. “Oh, at that point, I would’ve been lowkey impressed, while
internally screaming, ‘No, nooo, this isn’t how it’s supposed to go! We’re heading for a fall, and I didn’t come all the way out here to see her
succeed! Where’s my Anne-takes-a-tumble moment?’”
Jan nodded through her laughter. “But she did seem so graceful, didn’t she? Like, it was
just believable enough, even for me, that she might actually make it.”
“
Exactly. I would've been... fascinated,” Lily said, leaning in, her voice low as though she were narrating a suspenseful thriller. “Watching her tiptoeing on those stones, perfectly balancing her spotless Sperrys juuuust above the mud, and I’d be thinking, ‘Oh God, she's really
doing it. This is happening. She’s gonna make it. Anne, the preppy Amazon queen, is going to escape the mud without a
scratch.’” She clapped her hands dramatically, eyes wide, as if emphasizing the tension of that precise moment.
Jan was already shaking with laughter. “That’s where you’d think the story ends, right? With her doing this incredible balance-act in nature like some sort of preppy goddess?”
“Right?” Lily continued, eyes gleaming with amusement. “And it’s like, just when I’d have started to believe, just
maybe she was going to make it, then—oh hoh, then the slip would come. And I would
lose it. I mean, did you see the look on her face right in that moment?”
Jan gasped mid-laugh, clapping a hand to her mouth. “Oh, her expression was priceless. She was so
shocked.”
“I would
die of secondhand embarrassment,” Lily said, breaking into giggles again. “Watching her pretty new Sperrys just sink into the mud—I’d have thought, ‘There it is. Gravity remembered it has work to do.’ Her wide eyes, like she couldn’t believe a
whole part of the planet just reached up and betrayed her. I’d probably be muttering to myself, ‘
RIP Sperrys.’”
Jan was practically in tears again. “It was
so perfect. First step back. Squelch. And then the arms. Oh. My. God. The
flailing. I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone fight a fall as intensely as she did.”
Lily shook her head, still laughing. “I’m telling you, right then, I’d be standing there thinking, ‘She’s not going to win this battle. No way.’ While plotting the exact moment when I’d have to stop laughing long enough to help her out. You just feel it in the air—the inevitable plunge.”
“And that plunge,” Jan began, wiping away a tear. “It wasn’t just any fall. Oh no. It was a full
flop backward, arms outstretched, a beautiful disaster.”
Lily snorted with laughter. “I would’ve been completely
silent for the briefest moment, just
processing the sheer spectacle of the fall. And then, oh my God, I would’ve
died laughing. Just
died. It’s one of those things where you try to keep it together because you know she’s
mortified, but like… at the same time?”
Jan grinned, nodding. “You can’t not laugh. It’s a force of nature beyond your control.”
“Exactly!" Lily agreed. “I’d honestly be half-proud of her that she managed so well for so long. I mean, she
almost made it! But that fall? That look of horrified realization when she finally hit the mud? Oh man, I’d have pictures of that expression burned into my brain for years.”
“And after she just
sat there? In the mud, still trying to process how her perfect outfit went from runway-ready to ruined swamp creature?” Jan mimicked Anne's stunned, frozen pose.
“Oh, at that point, I’d be thinking, ‘I
cannot believe this woman was sailing through
two seconds ago like a model on a balance beam, and here we are.’” Lily laughed, throwing her arms up in mock surrender.
Jan laughed harder, clutching her sides. “And you know Anne, she’d be doing this mix of soul-crushing disappointment and trying to act like, ‘Oh, no big deal. Totally normal. I’ll just sit here in the mud now.’”
“That’s the part that kills me,” Lily giggled. “The way she’d try
so hard to salvage her dignity while covered in mud. But let’s be real: the second she was submerged in the mess, it was game over."
Jan wiped her eyes, still chuckling. “Lily, I swear, if you had been there, we would’ve both lost it. Anne would never let us live it down.”
“Oh, 100%. And even if she never brings it up again, we
know it happened. That image will live in our minds forever,” Lily replied, raising her coffee cup for another mock toast. “To the great fall of Anne.”
“May she always avoid future mud baths,” Jan added, clinking her cup with Lily’s as the two dissolved once again into uncontrollable laughter.