What else was Lauren wearing that day? What color stripe did she have on the Tretorns? Were the others in the group "taking bets" on how long she'd be able to keep them clean? What was the speculation at the creek? Was she going to make it? How close did she come to making it? What other comments did the guys and gals make to her after she sank in the mud?
Natalie giggled again, shaking her head as the memory of Lauren’s ill-fated hike unfolded more vividly with each passing second. "Oh, you remember Lauren—we always said she could make any trip to a grocery store look like a runway. So naturally, she came fully coordinated that day. She was wearing those bright white Tretorns with the
navy blue stripe, you know, the classic ones. And she had on these high-waisted light-wash jeans, cuffed at the bottom, and a perfectly tucked-in pale pink top. Oh, and let’s not forget—she was rocking a
white baseball cap and a matching white windbreaker! Who wears
that much white on a trail hike?"
Mary burst into laughter, waving her hand dismissively. "She was practically
glowing, Nat! Like a walking canvas commercial. I think even the birds were confused about what she was doing in the woods."
Natalie nodded, wiping a happy tear from her eye. "I swear, you could see the fear in her eyes with every step we took that was slightly off the beaten path. The dirt, the leaves—they were
closing in on her, and everyone was secretly taking bets on how long she'd last before disaster struck."
Mary’s eyes widened. "Wait, people were actually
taking bets?"
Natalie grinned mischievously. "Oh, absolutely! You didn’t notice? The minute we saw her shiny white shoes, Kyle was like, ‘I give her ten minutes before something gets trashed.’ And then Matt and Jenna joined in with their own predictions. Jenna thought Lauren could make it until lunch, but
Matt—Matt was ruthless. He was like, ‘Five bucks says those shoes don’t make it past the first mud puddle.’”
“Oh my
gosh, I didn’t hear any of that!” Mary was fully in giggles, clutching her stomach. “And what about when we got to the creek? Did the speculation just
skyrocket?”
Natalie’s eyes twinkled, and she started laughing all over again. “Oh,
you know it! The second we got to that creek and saw the mud around the edges—" Natalie paused, wiping her eyes and adopting an overdramatic serious tone, "It was like we were at the main event; everyone was watching Lauren out of the corner of their eyes, trying to act casual
but totally not casual. It was like being in a suspense movie. We were all thinking, ‘
This is it. This is her downfall. The pristine sneakers won’t survive this.’ We were all just waiting for the moment.”
Mary was practically tearing up from laughter now. "And she was trying to make it, wasn’t she? Like, really doing the most to stay clean?”
Natalie nodded enthusiastically, her grin wide. "Ohhhh yeah, for sure. The rest of us just trudged through a slightly muddy spot to cross, no biggie. But Lauren? She was standing there on the edge of the creek like she was planning her escape from Alcatraz. I swear she spent, like, a
full minute eyeing up the rocks, measuring steps with her eyes, and going over her
perfect sneaker survival strategy. I could almost hear her internally giving herself a pep talk. She had this determination in her face like, ‘I will
not be defeated by mud.’”
“She was so close, wasn’t she?” Mary asked, shaking her head, almost feeling bad for remembering the chaos that ensued.
Natalie nodded, letting out a big breath. "Oh, SO close. Her feet were practically hovering over every rock, and she was making these tiny little precision hops, trying to avoid even the tiniest splash. I remember Jenna whispered, ‘She might actually make it.’ But then—"
Natalie lifted her arms dramatically, as if to punctuate the moment.
"—her foot just barely slipped on the last rock. Not a lot, just enough for her balance to get thrown off. The last thing she probably saw before disaster struck was the look of
pure panic on all our faces as we realized she was
done for. She went to catch herself, but instead? Bam.
Straight into the mud. She didn’t even have a chance to scream—she just let out this ‘NOOOO!’ as one of her feet
sank. The left Tretorn was immediately submerged, and she froze, like she couldn’t believe what just happened.”
Mary gasped, placing a hand over her mouth. "It’s all coming back now! Her face was
priceless—like she’d just walked into a tragic fashion crime scene! And she didn’t even try to save herself. She just stood there, didn’t she?"
Natalie grinned wickedly. "Yup! She was
paralyzed, just staring down at her foot like the mud monster had stolen her soul. And we all just lost it—everyone burst out laughing. Kyle was like, ‘Welp, we all knew it would happen!’ Matt was
howling, saying he was ready to collect his five dollars. Even Jenna was trying to hold in her laughter but
failed so hard."
Mary clutched her stomach as she bent over, laughing. "And what about the comments from the guys? They were
merciless."
“Ohhh, they were brutal,” Natalie said, snickering. “Kyle was like, ‘Maybe the forest defeated you, but now you’ve got a
real “earthy” aesthetic going, Lauren.’ And Matt—oh my gosh—Matt was like, ‘Don’t worry, those Tretorns just needed a little more “character.” They look more
vintage now.’” Natalie giggled again, mimicking Matt’s laid-back vibe with air quotes.
Mary shook her head, barely able to contain herself. "And Lauren was just
shaking with frustration!"
Natalie flung her hand in the air dramatically. "Oh, you could see it—you could practically
feel her soul leaving her body. She was
furious. And remember when she started trying to gingerly step out of the mud and just made it worse? Like, every time she lifted her foot, it made that
squelching sound, and the mud was just
everywhere. And the kicker? The more she tried to fix it, the more she
dug herself in.”
Mary wiped her eyes. "And when we finally got out of the creek, she kept angrily muttering about how mud wasn’t ‘in the group chat.’ I think she genuinely believed we should’ve sent a warning.”
Natalie nodded, still grinning. "She was like, ‘Why didn’t anyone TELL me we’d be crossing
this?’ Meanwhile, all of us are like… Lauren, it’s a
trail hike, not tea time at your grandma’s! What did you expect?"
Mary let out one last huge laugh. “Poor girl was
traumatized! But I think the worst part? By the time we made it halfway down the trail, she gave up on even
trying to stay clean.”
“Oh, definitely,” Natalie agreed. “I think once the mud got into her shoes, it was over. Her shoulders slumped, her face fell, and she was just like, ‘Well, that’s it. I live in the dirt now.’ We practically had to
drag her back to the car, shoes still squishing every step of the way.”
Mary sighed, still grinning. "That was such a legendary moment. I guess I shouldn’t feel too bad about my Keds incident."
Natalie smirked. "Nope, you’re
definitely not alone in the ‘pristine shoes, meet the mud’ tragedy club. Lauren’s legacy lives on!"
Mary shook her head, still smiling. "
Never will I ever wear white shoes on a trail again."
Natalie laughed one last time. “Famous last words!